ENDTIME
ISSUES NEWSLETTER No. 179
ÒThe
Christian and Alcoholic BeveragesÓ
Samuele
Bacchiocchi, Ph. D.,
Retired
Professor of Theology and Church History,
Andrews
University
INDEX
OF TOPICS OF THIS NEWSLETTER
*
How to Subscribe and Unsubscribe
*
A New Outreach Book entitled Popular Unbiblical Beliefs
*
A New DVD Album: Abundant
Life Seminar
"The
Christian and Alcoholic Beverages"
(The
Essay of this Newsletter)
ANNOUNCEMENT
OF SERVICES & PRODUCTS
*
First Time Special offer on the Package of 10 DVD/
CD
albums, containing all the recordings of Prof. Jon
Paulien,
Prof, Graeme Bradford, and Prof. Bacchiocchi.
The
package includes also the newly released Abundant Life
DVD album.
*
Introductory offer on Prof. Jon PaulienÕs DVD album
on Simply Revelation
*
Special offer on the new edition of Prof.
Bradford
More than a Prophet, together with a free DVD album.
*
Upcoming seminars for August, and September
*
Incredible Offer on the new Hitachi 3000 Lumens Projector
Only $1395.00
*
The Smallest and most Powerful Remote Presenter
*
Does your church or School Need a Screen?
*
Bed and Breakfast in London, England
*
TAGNET new Web-hosting offer
HOW
TO SUBSCRIBE AND UNSUBSCRIBE
How
to unsubscribe to this newsletter:
To automatically unsubscribe simply send an empty message to: <mailto:[email protected]> Be sure the message is from your subscribed
email account or the system will not recognize you). If you have a problem or donÕt receive
a prompt unsubscription confirmation, send us an email at <mailto:[email protected]> saying Òunsubscribe meÓ and we will ask TAGNET to remove your
address manually.
How
to subscribe to this newsletter:
To
subscribe simply click on this address and send it:
mailto:[email protected]
No additional words or explanations are necessary. The TAGNET is set up to
automatically add your address to the list. If you have a problem, send us
an email at <mailto:[email protected]>
saying Òsubscribe me,Ó and we will ask TAGNET to enter your address manually.
A
PROPOSED NEW OUTREACH BOOK ENTITLED POPULAR UNBIBLICAL BELIEFS
In the last newsletter no. 178, I
mentioned the encouragement I received from several subscribers to publish a
book that exposes the unbiblical teachings of Catholic and Protestant churches,
while affirming the biblical beliefs of the Adventist church. I suggested as a
possible title POPULAR HERESIES.
The
responses I received show an overwhelming support for this project. The major
complaint regards the title POPULAR HERESIES which is perceived to be too
confrontations. After further reflection, I have come to the conclusion that
the observation is valid. What do you think of the title: POPULAR UNBIBLICAL
BELIEFS? Your suggestions for a suitable title are greatly appreciated
as I am struggling to find an attractive title.
The
sponsors of this project are willing to cover most of the expenses for
researching and printing 100,000 copies of Popular Unbiblical Beliefs. The idea is to offer the book to churches
at a minimum cost of only $2.00 or 3.00, primarily to cover the mailing
expenses. The regular price for this 320 pages book would be $25.00. On August
17, 2007, when I fly to Los Angeles to speak at the White Memorial Church, I am
scheduled to have breakfast with the coordinator of this project to discuss
some of the details.
What
do you think of this project? Do you feel that we badly need for our witnessing
outreach a book exposing the unbiblical beliefs of our times? Are you willing to pass out this book
to your friends? Would you consider contributing financially to the realization
of this project? Your input is greatly appreciated. Let me know what you think.
Personally
I feel that we urgently need a book to help our Catholic and Protestant friends
understand why some of their cherished beliefs are unbiblical. The ultimate
goat of the book is not merely to expose the flaws of some popular beliefs, but
to help people appreciate the biblical validity and timeliness of our Adventist
beliefs. To my knowledge our
Adventist church has never published a substantive book that helps people to
understand the difference between our Adventist beliefs and those
Catholic/Protestant churches. We can hardly expect people to accept our
Adventist beliefs, if we do not show them first why their beliefs are
unbiblical.
Popular
Unbiblical Beliefs will
examine the historical origin and the biblical flaws of a dozen popular beliefs
such as Papal Primacy, Immortality of the Soul, Sunday Sacredness, the
Eucharist, Intercession of Mary and the Saints, Indulgences, Eternal Torment in Hell, Once Saved
Always Saved, the Rapture, Speaking in Tongues, Infant Baptism, the Sacraments,
Mary's Immaculate Conception and Ascension to Heaven, the Use of Icons as an
Aid to Worship, the Use of Alcoholic Beverages, etc. Feel free to suggest any
additional belief that should be included.
My
intent is to write the book in a confessional, rather than confrontational way.
The style will be popular but profound. I plan to share the findings of my research, not subjective feelings
against other
churches. Its ultimate goal is to
help people of all faiths to understand and accept fundamental Bible truths God
has called us to proclaim. We believe that the time has come to sound God's
final call to mankind: "Come
out of her, my people, lest you take part in her sins" (Rev 18:4).
NEWLY
RELEASED DVD ALBUM CALLED ABUNDANT LIFE SEMINAR
At the request of the World's Woman's
Christian Temperance Union, a special video taping was professionally done at Andrews
University last August 8, 2007, of my powerpoint lecture on The Christian and Alcoholic Beverages.
The lecture summarizes the highlights of
my book Wine in the Bible. With the help of 125 powerpoint slides, I share the findings of my
research which shows that the Bible clearly teaches total abstinence, and not
moderation.
This
lecture will be delivered live at the International Convention of the World Woman's Christian Temperance Union (WWCTU)-an organization to which Ellen White
actively supported. The President, Sarah Ward, has already invited me on two
previous occasions. This year the
International WWCTU is held in Indianapolis from September 14-16, 2007, and
brings together Temperance Leaders from different parts of the world.
The
delegates are eager to obtain the live video recording of my lecture on The
Christian and Alcoholic Beverages, in order for them to show it to their congregations back home.
For the benefit of our subscribers who will not be able to attend the
convention, I decided to post in this newsletter a transcript of the lecture.
As you will soon discover, the lecture covers a lot of material.
If you live in Indianapolis, you are
welcomed to attend the convention. I am scheduled to deliver my lecture The
Christian and Alcoholic Beverages on Sabbath morning, September 15, at 10:00 a. m. The convention is
held at the AdamÕs Mark Hotel, 2544 Executive Drive, Indianapolis, IN 46241.
The hotel phone number is: (317) 248-2481. For directions and further detailed information, contact
Sarah R. Ward, WWCTU President, at (765) 345-2306
In
order to make full use of the DVD disk, we video taped on the same evening a
second powerpoint lecture entitled How to Build a Happy and Lasting
Marriage. This is one of
my favorite sermon that I have presented in many parts of the world. In this
sermon I share the highlights of my book The Marriage Covenant, by presenting 10 biblical principles for
building a happy and lasting marriage. I use 100 powerpoint slides to deliver
this practical lecture, which has been warmly received by congregations in
different parts of the world.
The
DVD album with both of these lectures, is entitled ABUNDANT LIFE SEMINAR and is ready for distribution. At this time we offer this ABUNDANT
LIFE DVD album at the special introductory
offer of only $50.00, instead of the regular price of $100.00. The price
includes the AIRMAILING to any foreign country.
You
can order this timely DVD album online by clicking at this link: http://www.biblicalperspectives.com/cart/catalog/product_info.php?cPath=23&products_id=102
If
you have a problem ordering online, feel free to call us at (269) 471-2915 and
we will take your order by phone. Thank you for sharing these timely messages
with your friends and congregation.
SPECIAL
FIRST TIME OFFER OF 10 DVD/CD ALBUMS FOR ONLY $150.00, INSTEAD OF THE REGULAR
PRICE OF $950.00
For the first time I am offering together
as a package all the DVD/CD recordings of Prof. Jon Paulien, Prof. Graeme
Bradford, and my own. Note that the package includes also the newly recorded ABUNDANT
LIFE SEMINAR DVD album. If you were to purchase
online all these recordings separately it would cost you $950.00. But to make
it possible for many to benefit from all these timely messages, I have decided
to offer them together as a package for only $150.00, instead of the regular price of $950.00.
The
package consists of 10 DVD/CD albums, containing a total of 22 live DVD lectures
and 6 CD disks with publications and articles. For a detailed description
and picture of each album click at this link: http://www.biblicalperspectives.com/albumoffer.htm
Further
information is provided at the end of this newsletter in the Announcements of
Services and Products.
ÒThe
Christian and Alcoholic BeveragesÓ
Samuele
Bacchiocchi, Ph. D.,
Retired
Professor of Theology and Church History,
Andrews
University
Editorial
Note
Every Endtime Issues
Newsletter has a story behind.
This one is no exception.
The story began with a letter (dated January 22, 2007) I received from
Sarah Ward, the President of the WorldÕs WomanÕs Christian Temperance Union
(WWCTU). She invited me to deliver the keynote address at their international
convention to be held in Indianapolis on September 14-16, 2007. The WWCTU is an international
organization committed to promote total abstinence as a biblical, moral
imperative.
Ellen
White was very active in this temperance society which she promoted through her
speeches and writings. Eventually this led to the establishment of Temperance
Societies in our Adventist Churches which have survived until the early 1980s. At that time the
Temperance Societies ceased to exist, partly because the Temperance Department
was replaced with the Health Ministry Department of the GC. The latter promotes
abstinence primarily as a health benefit, rather than as a biblical, moral imperative.
On
two previous occasions, I have been invited to share the highlights of my book Wine
in the Bible at national
conventions of the WWCTU. The forthcoming convention is international, bringing
together temperance leaders from about 30 countries. I have been asked to
produce a video taping of the lecture to make available to the participants at
the convention. This will make it possible for them to share this research in
their respective countries.
During
the past few weeks I have spent countless hours preparing this powerpoint
lecture entitled The Christian and Alcoholic Beverages. I deliver this
lecture with the help of 125 powerpoint slides, which illustrate the highlights
of my book Wine in the Bible. The video taping was professional done on
Wednesday evening, August 8, 2007.
In order to make full use of the DVD disk, we taped also my lecture
entitled How to Build a Happy and Lasting Marriage. The DVD album with
the two lectures is called ABUNDANT LIFE SEMINAR and is now available
for distribution. Below you will find the order information.
This
newsletter is largely the expanded transcript of the powerpoint lecture on The
Christian and Alcoholic Beverages. You will soon discover that this is a
lengthy essay because it addresses many vital aspects of this subject. If you
find this study informative and inspiring, feel free to print it and give it,
especially to people who have a drinking problem. Even better, you may wish to
share the live video lecture, which people can watch on their TV.
It
is my fervent hope that this study, the fruit of dedicated research, may help
many Christians of all denominations to better understand and accept the fact
that drinking alcoholic beverages is not only physically harmful, but also
Biblically and morally wrong. It represents the violation of a principle God
has given us to ensure our
physical, mental and spiritual well-being.
THE
CHRISTIAN AND ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGES
A Look at
the Drinking Problem
The use of
alcoholic beverages is a most critical area of Christian living in the world
today. In America, according to a recent Gallup Poll (July 6-8, 2006), 64 per
cent of Americans (about 200 million) drink alcoholic beverages. Many of the drinkers are Christians who
believe that the Bible sanctions the moderate use of alcoholic beverages.
In American
Colleges drinking has reached alarming proportions. The US National Institute of Alcohol Abuse and Alcoholism,
reports the following sobering alcohol-related incidents for the year 2002
among college students:
Deaths: 1,400
Injuries: 5,000
Assaults: 600,000 students assaulted by students
who had been drinking
Sexual
Assaults: 70,000 victims
of alcohol related sexual assaults or date rape
Sex: 100,000 said they were too drunk to know
if the consented to having sex
Driving: 2.1 million drove under the influence of
alcohol.
The consumption
of alcohol affects not only the social behavior of students, but also their
academic performance. A study sponsored by the Florida Atlantic University
Center for Alcohol and Drug Prevention, shows the relationship that exists
between the average number of drinks consumed per week and the grade point
average. These are the figures shown in the colorful chart used in the
powerpoint lecture.
3.6
Drinks = A
5.5
Drinks = B
7.6
Drinks = C
10.6
Drinks = D/F
The reason alcohol consumption affects academic
performance, is simply because alcohol impairs the functioning of the brain.
Today, with the help of sophisticated
brain scanner, called Functional Magnetic Resonance Imaging (FMRI), scientists
can see that the brain of drinkers is less active and responsive to memory
tasks than the brain of non-drinkers (Alcoholism: Clinical & Experimental
Research, Feb. 14, 2001). In
the powerpoint presentation you can see in bright colors the impressive image
of the brain response of drinkers and non-drinkers. (http://health.ucsd.edu/news/2001/02_09_fMRI.html).
The harmful effects
of alcoholic beverages extend beyond the brain, to all the major organs of
the human body. They can cause blurred vision, blurred speech, bleeding throat,
breathing problems, irregular heart beat, stomach ulcers, liver diseases,
intestinal cancer, impotence in men, infertility in women, and osteoporosis.
These harmful effects are graphically illustrated in a most colorful image
found at www.thelivercentre.com.au/development/alcohol/default.htm
and included in the powerpoint presentation.
A Gallup Poll indicates that 1 out of
every 4 American families (about 70 million) is affected by alcohol-related
problems such as divorce, retarded children, violence in the home, crime,
sickness and death. These problems are even more intense in Eastern European
countries and Russia, where vodka is cheap and readily available.
Social analysts
informs us that the use of alcoholic beverages has become AmericaÕs number-one
public enemy, costing over $117 billion a year and claiming at least 100,000
American lives per year, 25 times as many as all illegal drugs combined.
The consumption
of alcoholic beverages is not a unique American problem. It is present in most
developed and developing countries. For example, France has the highest
consumption of wine in the world as well as the highest mortality rate of
cirrhosis of the liver: about 30,000 every year. The real human cost of alcohol
transcends any statistical estimate of deaths, disabilities or dollar
figures.
A
Christian Responsibility
Christian
churches bear considerable responsibility for the alcohol epidemic raging in
America today, because through their beliefs, teachings and preaching they are
able to influence the moral values and practices of society more than any other
institution. What pastors preach
from their pulpits on the subject of drinking determines to a large extent the
stand Christians take toward alcoholic beverages. A majority of the 200 million drinkers in America today are
churchgoers who have been taught that the Bible sanctions a moderate use of
alcoholic beverages. Moderate
drinking has led million of
Americans to become immoderate drinkers, because alcohol is a habit-forming
narcotic that weakens oneÕs capacity for self-control.
Temperance
Societies
A century ago most churches actively
promoted total abstinence through Temperance Societies. Several temperance
societies were established such as the American Temperance Society in 1826, the
American Temperance Union in 1836, the National Prohibition Party in 1869, the
WomenÕs Christian Temperance Union in 1874, and the politically oriented
Anti-Saloon League in 1893.
The history of
the temperance movement in America indicates that the cause of total abstinence
was most enthusiastically embraced and promoted by those evangelical churches
which stood for total abstinence such as the Baptist, Methodist,
Congregationalist, New School Presbyterian, Salvation Army, some holiness
movements and the Seventh-day Adventist Church. Their fervor was inspired by the conviction that Scripture
teaches abstinence from intoxicating beverages rather than moderation in their
use.
These movements
eventually achieved Prohibition by the passing of the Eighteenth Amendment to
the Constitution of the United States on January 16, 1919. This Amendment outlawed the
Òmanufacture, sale or transportationÓ of alcoholic beverages.
Prohibition came
to an end on December 5, 1933 with the adoption of the Twenty-first Amendment
to the Constitution, which legalized the production and consumption of
alcoholic beverages. Since then most churches have abandoned their stand for
total abstinence, promoting instead moderation. As a result, the drinking levels of Americans have risen
again, bringing with them a trail of sickness, poverty, crime and death.
From
Abstinence to Moderation
The increased consumption of alcoholic
beverages, is partly due to the failure of church leaders to uphold biblical
moral principles. The concern of evangelical preachers is to teach people how
to be saved, rather than to explain how to live the new life in Christ. For
most preachers drinking is not a moral issue because they believe the Bible teaches
moderation, not abstinence.
The situation was
much different in the 18th and 19th centuries when most churches, and
influential preachers like John Wesley, boldly taught total abstinence as a
biblical, moral imperative. The same was true also in the Seventh-day Adventist
Church, where Ellen White served as a powerful champion of total
abstinence. She wrote: ÒThe Lord
has given special directions in His Word in reference to the use of wine and
strong drink. He has forbidden their use and enforced His prohibition with
strong warnings and threateningsÓ (Temperance 42, Emphasis supplied).
The strong stand
for total abstinence, promoted by Ellen White and by popular preachers of her
time, has gradually been abandoned by Evangelical Churches, which have
adopted instead a moderationist
position toward alcohol use.
A major factor which has contributed to this trend has been a weakening
of the conviction that total abstinence is a clear biblical and moral principle
to be respected like other God-given principles.
Billy Graham
expressed this view when he said:
ÒI do not believe that the Bible teaches teetotalism . . . Jesus drank
wine. Jesus turned water into wine
at a wedding feast. That wasnÕt
grape juice as some of them try to claimÓ (Miami Herald, December 26, 1976, section A, p. 18).
This popular belief has affected also the Seventh-day Adventist Church.
Contrary to Ellen WhiteÕs bold stand for
total abstinence as a biblical imperative, the Adventist Church
today believes that ÒTotal
abstinence is but one of a number
of areas where the Bible gives no explicit directivesÓ (Adventist Review, Feb 22, 1982).
No longer having
a compelling Biblical and moral conviction to remain or become abstinent, more
and more Christian are giving in to the social pressure of drinking alcohol. This is happening also in our Seventh-day
Adventist church, long known as a champion of temperance and abstinence. I have been made forcibly aware of this
trend by such things as: frequent
pleas for help from pastors and members facing drinking problems in their own
congregations; published surveys in our church paper, Adventist Review,
indicating that 58 percent of
Adventist youth are experimenting with alcohol and 17 percent of
Adventist College students are habitual drinkers (Adventist Review, October 29, 1987, pp. 6-7); lectures given on our college campuses
on alcohol recovery by visiting non-SDA experts; classes on substance abuse taught on our campuses;
counseling centers set up on our campuses specifically to help students with
drinking problems.
My
Decision to Write Wine in the Bible
When I became aware of the gradual
change in the Evangelical and
Adventist positions on the biblical teachings on drinking and of the
alarming drinking problems in our society, I decided to devote a
leave-of-absence from my teaching at Andrews University to conduct an in-depth
study of what the Bible has to say on the use of alcoholic beverages. The
results of this research has been published in Wine in the Bible: A Biblical Study on the Use of
Alcoholic Beverages (300
pages, 1989).
The book has been
favorably reviewed by over one hundred scholars and church leaders of different
denominations. You can read a
sampling of their comments by clicking at this link: www.biblicalperspectives.com/comments/ This essay represents a nutshell summary
of the highlights of this research, which I presented with 125 slides in the
newly recorded DVD album entitled ABUNDANT LIFE SEMINAR.
An
Apparent Contradiction
When I began
reading all the biblical reference to wine, it soon became evident that the
Bible speaks about wine in an apparent contradictory way.
As I began
reading what Scripture teaches about the use of wine, it soon became evident
that the Bible speaks on this subject in an apparent contradictory way. On the one hand, the Bible unreservedly
disapproves of use of wine (Lev 10:8-11;
Judg 13:3, 4; Prov 31:4,
5; 23:31; 20:1; Hab 2:5; Eph 5:18; 1 Tim 3:2, 3). ÒDo not look at wineÓ
(Prov 23:31); ÒWine is treacherousÓ (Hab 2:5); ÒDrink no wine nor strong drinkÓ (Lev 10:9). But, on the
other hand the Bible wholeheartedly approves the use of wine as a divine
blessing for people to enjoy (Gen 27:28;
49:10-12; Ps 104:14,
15; Is 55:1; Amos 9:13; John 2:10, 11). ÒGod gives wine to gladden the heartÓ (Ps
104:15).
Three major
explanations are generally given to resolve the apparent contradiction between
the biblical approval and disapproval of the use of wine:
¥ The
Moderationist View
¥ The
Concessionist View
¥ The
Prohibitionist View
The
Moderationist View
Advocates of
moderation attempt to resolve this apparent contradiction by arguing that
Scripture condemns the immoderate use of alcoholic beverages and commends their moderate use. This belief is based on the assumption
that the Bible knows only of fermented wine (Òone wine theoryÓ) which it
considers as a divine blessing when used with moderation. Consequently any condemnation of wine
in the Bible refers not to the kind of wine (alcoholic), but to the amount
consumed. In his book, God Gave Wine, Kenneth Gentry defends the
moderationist view, saying:
ÒScripture allows wine to be consumed both for health and pleasure—but in
moderationÓ
A major weakness
of this view is that Scripture both condemns and commends wine per se,
irrespective of the quantity used.
Wine is denounced as ÒtreacherousÓ (Hab 2:5) and as Òa mockerÓ (Prov
20:1) that Òbites like a serpent and stings like an adderÓ (Prov 23:32). To avoid the shame and suffering caused
by drinking fermented wine, Scripture admonishes not moderation but total
abstinence: ÒDo not look at wineÓ (Prov 23:31). The reason for this absolute prohibition is no doubt the
fact that gazing at something attractive is the first step toward partaking it.
The
Concessionist View
Others try to
resolve the apparent contradiction between the Biblical approval and
disapproval of wine, by arguing that the positive references represent a divine
concession to human failings, similar to divorce. This view has been adopted in
recent years by our Seventh-day Adventist Church. For example the book Seventh-day
Adventist Believe . . . states:
ÒScriptural stories involving the use of alcoholic beverages may give the
impression that God approved their use.
However, Scripture also indicates that GodÕs people participated in
social practices . . . that God certainly did not condone. In interpreting such Scriptural
passages, it is helpful to keep in mind that God does not necessarily endorse
all that He permitsÓ (p. 282).
A major problem
with this interpretation is that some passages speak of Òwine,Ó not as a divine
concession to human failings but as a divine blessing for the people to
enjoy. For example, the Psalmist
says that God gives Òwine to gladden the heart of man, oil to make his face shine,
and bread to strengthen manÕs heartÓ (Ps104:14,15). Here ÒwineÓ is joined together with food and oil as a basic
divine blessing which enjoys GodÕs approval.
Similarly, in
Isaiah 55:1 GodÕs free offer of His mercy is likened to the free reception of
water, wine and milk: ÒHo, everyone who thirsts, come to the waters; and he who
has no money, come, buy and eat!
Come, buy wine [yayin] and milk without money and without price.Ó The fact that Òwine and milkÓ are here
paired together as symbols of good and satisfying spiritual benefits suggests
again that ÒwineÓ (yayin) was not merely permitted but also approved. Other examples indicating divine
approval for wine can be found in those passages which describe wine as the
symbol of prosperity and gladness of the messianic age.
The
Prohibitionist View
The
prohibitionist view maintains that the apparent contradiction between the
Biblical approval and disapproval of the use of wine can best be resolved by
recognizing that the same Hebrew and Greek words for wine (yayin and oinos) can refer both to unfermented grape
juice and to fermented wine.
Consequently the ÒwineÓ God approves of is uniformly unfermented grape
juice and the ÒwineÓ He disapproves is fermented and intoxicating.
According to this
view, alcoholic beverages are prohibited in Scripture as unfit for human
consumption. To partake of them is
not only unhealthy but also immoral, because it represents the violation of a
Biblical principle designed to ensure our health and holiness. This is the view that I have come to
accept, after a careful examination of all the Biblical references to drinking
Òwine.Ó I was pleasantly surprised
to discover that Ellen White, who greatly influenced the Seventh-day Adventist
Church in the adoption of the Biblical principle of abstinence, clearly
espouses the prohibitionist view.
Three
Reasons for the Confusion
There are three
major reasons for the confusion on the biblical teachings on the use of
alcoholic beverages. The first reason is that most Christians mistakenly
believe that the Bible knows only the fermented wine. The Hebrew (yayin) and Greek (oinos) words for Òwine,Ó supposedly refer only
to alcoholic wine. Shortly we will
show that this belief is discredited by the historical use of these two terms
to describe the juice of the grapes whether fermented or unfermented.
The second reason
is the popular assumption that in Bible times it was impossible to preserve
grape juice unfermented. We shall see that this assumption is discredited by
ancient documents which mentions the various methods used to preserve grape
juice unfermented.
The third reason
for the confusion is the fact that the apostolic admonitions to total
abstinence, expressed through nepho/nephalios, have been mistranslated as ÒBe soberÓ
instead of ÒBe abstinent.Ó These admonitions will be discussed in the latter
part of this Bible Study.
The
Outline of this Bible Study
For the sake of clarity, this Bible Study
is divided in the following five parts:
The
Meaning of ÒWineÓ
The Preservation
of Grape Juice
Jesus and
Wine
Wine in
the Apostolic Church
Biblical
Reasons for Abstinence
THE
MEANING OF ÒWINEÓ
The prevailing assumption is that the
Hebrew and Greek words for wine (yayin and oinos) always mean Òfermented wine.Ó Is this assumption correct? To find an answer to this
question I investigated the
Biblical and historical usage of the term Òwine,Ó beginning from the English wine, and then proceeding backward to the Latin vinum, the Greek oinos and finally the Hebrew yayin.
The result of the survey is abundantly clear: these four related words
have been used historically to refer to the juice of the grape, whether
fermented or unfermented.
Most
modern English dictionaries define the word ÒwineÓ as the fermented juice of
grapes. This restrictive meaning
of ÒwineÓ represents, however, a departure from the more classical dual meaning
of the word as a designation for both fermented and unfermented grape juice. To verify this fact one needs
only to consult some older dictionaries.
For example, the 1955 Funk & Wagnalls New ÒStandardÓ Dictionary
of the English Language
defines ÒwineÓ as follows:
Ò1. The fermented juice of
the grape: in loose language the
juice of the grape whether fermented or not.Ó This definition shows that fifty years ago the loose usage
of ÒwineÓ referred to Òthe juice of the grape whether fermented or not.Ó
The
Meaning of the Greek Oinos
Examples of the dual usage oinos abound in secular Greek. In his book Metereologica,
Aristotle (384-322 B.C.) speaks of unfermented grape juice (glukus), saying: Òthough called wine [oinos], it has not the effect of wine, for it does not taste like wine
and does not intoxicate like ordinary wine.Ó In this text Aristotle explicitly informs us that
unfermented grape juice was called Òoinos—wine,Ó though it did not have the taste or the
intoxicating effect of ordinary wine.
In the
Septuagint, an intertestamental Greek translation of the Old Testament, Òthe Hebrew word for grape-juice, tirosh,Ó as Ernest Gordon points out, Ò is
translated at least 33 times by the Greek word oinos, wine, and the adjective ÔnewÕ is not
present. Oinos
without qualification, then, can easily mean unfermented wine in the New
Testament.Ó
The
Meaning of the Hebrew Yayin.
Like in Greek so in Hebrew the term for
ÒwineÓ (yayin) was
used to refer to either fermented or unfermented wine. The Jewish
Encyclopedia explains
that ÒFresh wine before fermenting was called Ôyayin mi-gatÕ
(wine of the vat; Sanh 70a).Ó
The Halakot Gedalot, which is the earliest Jewish compendium of the Talmud,
says: ÒOne may press out a cluster
of grapes and pronounce the Kiddush over the juice, since the juice of the grape is considered wine [yayin] in
connection with the laws of the Nazirite.Ó
The
use of yayin in the
Old Testament to denote unfermented grape juice is not always self-evident,
because it does not come under
condemnation like the fermented yayin. In several
passages, however, the context clearly indicates that the word designates
unfermented grape juice (Jer 40:10, 12; Neh 13:15; Lam 2:12; Gen 49:11; Songs
1:2, 4; 4:10). For example, Isaiah
16:10 speaks GodÕs judgment upon Moab,
manifested through the removal of the divine blessing from the vineyard
and the grape juice: ÒAnd joy and
gladness are taken away from the fruitful field; and in the vineyard no songs
are sung, no shouts are raised; no treader treads out wine [yayin] in the presses; the vintage shout is
hushedÓ (Is 16:10). The ÒwineÓ (yayin) the treaders tread out in the pressing
vat, is obviously unfermented
grape juice since fermentation is a time-controlled process.
The
above sampling of Biblical and historical testimonies suffice to show that the
Bible knows of both fermented wine, which it disapproves, and unfermented grape
juice, which it approves. This conclusion becomes clearer when we examine the
reasons for the Biblical disapproval of fermented wine and approval of
unfermented grape juice.
Two
Wines: Two Different Symbolic Meanings
The difference
between fermented and unfermented wine can be seen in the two different
symbolic meanings given to the beverages. The study of the Biblical approval of
ÒwineÓ shows a consistent pattern: all the positive references to ÒwineÓ have
to do with unfermented and unintoxicating grape juice.
Because of its natural and nourishing properties, grape juice
was fittingly used to represent the divine blessing of material prosperity (Gen
27:28; 49:10-11; Deut 33:28), the blessing of the
messianic age (Joel 2:18-19; Jer
31:10-12; Amos 9:13, 14), the free offer of GodÕs saving grace (Is 55:1), the
wholesome joy God offers to His people (Ps 104:14-15; 4:7), and the acknowledgment of God through the use of grape
juice as tithe, offerings and libations (Num 18:12; Deut 14:23; Ex
29:40; Lev 23:13). The reason is grape
juice is used as a positive symbol is because it is a healthy beverage that nourishes the body, without harming
vital organs like the liver and the brain.
Contrary to
unfermented wine, fermented wine is used in the Bible to represent apostasy,
immorality, corruption, and divine wrath (Is 19:14; Rev 14:10; 16:19; 17:2;
18:3). The reason for this negative symbology is that alcoholic beverages
distort the perception of reality (Is 28:7; Prov 23:33); they impair the capacity to make responsible
decisions (Lev 10:9-11); they weaken moral sensitivities and inhibitions (Gen
9:21; 19:32; Hab 2:15; Is 5:11-12); they cause physical sickness (Prov
23:20-21; Hos 7:5; Is 19:14; Ps 60:3); and they disqualify for both civil and religious
service (Prov 31:4-5; Lev
10:9-11; Ezek 44:23; 1 Tim 3:2-3; Titus 1:7-8). We shall discuss shortly some of these
reasons.
The foregoing
considerations indicate that the Biblical approval or disapproval of ÒwineÓ is
determined not by the amount of wine consumed but by the nature of the ÒwineÓ
itself. The positive references to
ÒwineÓ have to do with unfermented, unintoxicating grape juice. In contrast,
all the indictments of ÒwineÓ have to do with alcoholic, intoxicating
wine. The latter is condemned
irrespective of the quantity used.
THE PRESERVATION
OF GRAPE JUICE
A major objection
against the view that Scripture approves the use of unfermented grape juice is
the alleged impossibility in Bible times of preserving grape juice unfermented. To test the validity of this popular
assumption I investigated the testimonies of ancient writers regarding the art
of preserving fruits and wines in general and grape juice in particular. To my surprise I discovered that the
ancients were far more knowledgeable in the art of preserving fruits and wines
than is generally believed.
The
Preservation of Fermented Wine
Contrary to popular opinion, the problems
the ancients encountered in preserving fermented wine were as great as, if not
greater than those faced in preserving unfermented grape juice. To prevent fermented wine from becoming
acid, moldy, or foul-smelling, vintners used a host of preservatives such as
salt, sea-water, liquid or solid pitch, boiled-down must, marble dust, lime,
sulphur fumes or crushed iris.
In his Natural History, Pliny acknowledges the problem, saying:
ÒIt is a peculiarity of wine to go moldy or else to turn into vinegar; and
whole volumes of instructions on how to remedy this have been publishedÓ (Natural
History 14, 26). In some
places the risk of preserving fermented wine was so great that all the vintage
was boiled-down and preserved as sweet, unfermented grape juice. Columella, a
renowed agriculturalist who lived in the first century A. D., recommends for
Òany estate where wine often turns acidÓ to boil down all the must until a
tenth part of it has evaporated and thus preserve the whole vintage as
unfermented, boiled down wine (On Agriculture 12, 26, 1).
The
Preservation of Unfermented Grape Juice
In comparison to
fermented wine, the preservation of grape juice unfermented was a relatively
simpler process. Ancient sources
inform us that it was accomplished in four main ways: (1) by boiling down the juice to a syrup,
(2) by separating the fermentable pulp from the juice of the grape by means of
filtration, (3) by placing the
freshly pressed grape juice in sealed jars which were immersed in a pool of
cold water, and (4) by fumigating the wine jars with sulphur before sealing
them. These methods are discussed at length in chapter 4 of Wine in the
Bible.
For the sake of
brevity, we will mention here the boiling method. Columella discusses at great length the different
methods used to preserve grape juice unfermented. In speaking of its preservation by boiling, he writes: ÒSome
people put the must in leaden vessels and by boiling reduce it by a quarter,
others by a third.Ó He goes on
explaining that Òafterwards, when
it has cooled, you should pour it into vessels, cover it and seal it up; in
this way it will keep longer and no harm will befall itÓ (On Agriculture 12, 26, 1). The custom of preserving grape juice by
boiling it down into a syrup has survived through the centuries in the Near
East and Mediterranean countries. This beverage is known as vino cotto (boiled wine) in Italian, vin cuit in French, nardenk in Syriac and dibs in Arabic.
There are
indications that the ancient Jews preserved wine by boiling it. John KittoÕs Cyclopedia of Biblical
Literature says: ÒThe Mishna states that the Jews were in the habit of using boiled
wine. ÔThey do not boil the wine of the
heave-offering, because it diminishes it,Õ and consequently thickens it, thus rendering the mingling
of water with it when drunk necessary; but it is immediately added, ÔRabbi
Yehudah permits this because it improves itÕ (Teroomoth Perek 100, 11)Ó (Vol. 2, p. 477).
The fact that the
Old and New Testaments do not discuss the art of preserving grape juice, does
not mean that it was unknown in Bible times. The reason for the silence of
Scripture is to be found in the
nature of the Bible itself, a book which deals primarily with those aspects of
life which are related to salvation history.
JESUS AND WINE
The example and
teachings of Christ are normative for Christian belief and practice. If, as many well-meaning Christians
believe, Christ made fermented wine at the wedding of Cana,
commended it in the
parables of the new wine skins and the old wine, admitted to have used it in His description of His lifestyle (Òeating and
drinkingÓ) and commanded it to be used until
the end of time at the institution of the Lord's Supper, then there can hardly
be anything intrinsically wrong with a moderate drinking of alcoholic
beverages. Simply stated, ÒIf wine
was good enough for Jesus, it is good enough for me!Ó
In view of the
fundamental importance and far-reaching consequences of the example and teachings of Christ, I have
examined in chapter 5 of Wine in the Bible, the five wine stories and sayings
related to Jesus. For the sake of brevity, we will consider in this Bible Study
only two of them: The Wedding of Cana and The Communion Wine.
The
Wedding at Cana
Many well-meaning
Christians believe that the Ògood wineÓ Jesus made at Cana (John 2:10) was ÒgoodÓ because
of its high alcoholic content. The prevailing assumption is that the wine that
Jesus made was good, because it was high in alcoholic content. The text,
however, cannot be interpreted with the modern drinking mentality, but with the
mentality of Bible times. The
question is: What constituted
Ògood wineÓ in JesusÕ time? Furthermore, Was fermented wine used at wedding
celebrations? Could Jesus have produced over 100 gallons of intoxicating wine
for the use of men, women, and children? To answer this question, we will
consider three major lines of evidences:
¥ Witness of
Ancient Authors
¥ Jewish
Wedding Customs
¥ The Moral
Implications of ChristÕs Alleged Use of Fermented Wine
The
Witness of Ancient Authors
The prevailing
assumption is that the wine Jesus made at the Wedding of Cana, was pronounced
Òthe good wineÓ (John 2:10) by the master of the banquet, because it was high
in alcoholic content. This assumption is based on the taste of twenty-first century drinkers who
define the goodness of wine in proportion to its alcoholic strength. But this
was not necessarily true in the Roman world of New Testament times where the best
wines were those whose alcoholic potency had been removed by boiling or
filtration.
Pliny, for
example, says that Òwines are most beneficial (utilissimum) when all their potency has been removed
by the strainerÓ (Natural History 23, 24). Similarly,
Plutarch points out that wine is Òmuch more pleasant to drinkÓ when it Òneither
inflames the brain nor infests the mind or passionsÓ because its strength has been removed
through frequent filtering (Symposiac 8, 7).
The wine that
Christ made at Cana was of high quality, not because of its alcoholic content,
but because it was a pleasant new wine, freshly created. There was no time for the fermentation
process to break down the natural sugar into alcohol.
Jewish
Custom
A second discrediting evidence is the
Jewish custom of not offering fermented drinks at sacred festivals. The reason given is the presence of
women and children who were not allowed to drink alcoholic beverages. The
Talmud indicates that drinking to the accompaniment of musical instruments in
festive occasions such as a wedding was forbidden (See Sotah 48a; also Mishna Sotah 9, 11).
The latter is
confirmed by later testimonies of rabbis. For example, Rabbi S. M. Isaac, an eminent nineteenth-century
rabbi and editor of The Jewish Messenger, says: ÒThe
Jews do not, in their feasts for sacred purposes, including the marriage
feast, ever use any kind
of fermented drinks. In their
oblations and libations, both private and public, they employ the fruit of the
vine—that is, fresh grapes—unfermented grape-juice, and raisins, as
the symbol of benediction.
Fermentation is to them always a symbol of corruption.Ó
The Moral Implications
A third discrediting evidence is the
moral implications of the miracle. Those who wish to insist that the wine used
at the Wedding of Cana was alcoholic and that Jesus also provided alcoholic
wine, though of a better quality, are driven to the conclusion that Jesus
provided a large additional quantity of intoxicating wine so that the wedding
party could continue its reckless indulgence. Such a conclusion destroys the
moral integrity of Christ's character.
Moral consistency
demands that Christ could not have miraculously produced between 120 to 180
gallons of intoxicating wine for the use of men, women and children gathered at
the CanaÕs wedding feast, without becoming morally responsible for their
intoxication. Scriptural and moral
consistency requires that Òthe good wineÓ produced by Christ was fresh,
unfermented grape juice. This is
supported by the very adjective used to describe it, namely kalos,
which denotes that which is morally excellent, instead of agathos, which means simply good.
The
Communion Wine
Fundamental
importance is attached to the ÒwineÓ of the Last Supper because Christ not only
used it, but even commanded it to be used until the end of time as a memorial of His redeeming
blood (Matt 26:28-29; Mark
14:24-25). It is widely believed
that the wine of the Last Supper was alcoholic for two main reasons: (1) the
phrase "Òfruit of the vineÓ was allegedly used as the functional
equivalent of fermented wine, and (2) the Jews supposedly used only fermented
wine at the Passover. This belief
is discredited by the following four major evidences:
¥ The
Meaning of ÒFruit of the VineÓ
¥ The Nature
of the Passover Wine
¥ The
Consistency of the Symbol
¥ The
Survival of the Practice of Using Grape Juice
The
Meaning of ÒFruit of the VineÓ
A first reason
for believing that Jesus used unfermented wine at the Last Supper, is suggested
by the use of the phrase Òfruit of the vine.Ó In all the synoptic gospels Jesus calls the contents of the
cup Òthe fruit of the vineÓ (Matt 26:29; Mark 14:25; Luke 22:18). The noun
ÒfruitÓ (gennema)
denotes that which is produced in a natural state, just as it is gathered. Fermented wine is not the natural
Òfruit of the vineÓ but the unnatural fruit of fermentation and decay.
The Jewish
historian Josephus, who was a contemporary of the apostles, explicitly calls
the three clusters of grapes freshly squeezed in a cup by PharaophÕs cupbearer
as Òthe fruit of the vineÓ (Antiquities
of the Jews 2, 5,
2). This establishes unequivocally
that the phrase was used to designate the sweet, unfermented juice of the
grape.
In His divine
wisdom Christ chose to designate the content of the cup, the memorial of His
redeeming blood, Òthe fruit of the vine,Ó so that future generations of
Christians would find no sanction in His words, for using alcoholic wine at the
LordÕs Supper.
The
Passover Wine
A second reason
for believing that Jesus used unfermented grape juice at the Last Supper, is
suggested by the fact He understood and observed the Mosaic law requiring the
absence of all fermented articles during the Passover feast. The law forbade the use and presence in
the house of seor (Ex
12:15), which means leaven, yeast or whatever can produce fermentation.
Whatever had been
subject to the action of seor—that is fermentation, was also forbidden. This was called hametz and is translated Òleavened breadÓ in the
KJV (Ex 12:15; 13:7). The word
Òbread,Ó however, is not in the text; thus a more accurate translation is
Òfermented thing.Ó For seven days
the Jews were to partake of matzoth, usually translated Òunleavened breadÓ (Ex 13:6-7). As in the case of hametz, the word ÒbreadÓ is not in the text,
thus, a more accurate translation is Òunfermented things.Ó
Jesus understood
the meaning of the letter and spirit of the Mosaic law regarding Òunfermented
things,Ó as indicated by His warning against Òthe leaven of the Pharisees and SadduceesÓ (Matt
16:6). ÒLeavenÓ for Christ
represented corrupt nature and teachings, as the disciples later understood
(Matt 16:12). The consistency and
beauty of the blood symbolism
cannot be fittingly represented by fermented wine, which stands in the
Scripture for human depravity and divine indignation.
The
Consistency of the Symbol
A third reason for believing that Jesus
used unfermented wine at the Last Supper, is the consistency and beauty of the
blood symbolism which cannot be fittingly represented by fermented wine. Leaven was used by Christ to represent
the corrupt teachings of the Pharisees and is viewed in Scripture as an emblem
of sin and corruption. Could
Christ have offered His disciples a cup of fermented wine to symbolize His
untainted blood shed for the remission of our sins? Could the redeeming and cleansing blood of Christ have been
represented aptly by an intoxicating cup which stands in the Scripture for
human depravity and divine indignation?
We cannot
conceive of Christ bending over to bless in grateful prayer a cup containing
alcoholic wine which the Scripture warns us not to look at (Prov 23:31). A cup that intoxicates is a cup of
cursing and not Òthe cup of blessingÓ (1 Cor 10:16); it is Òthe cup of demonsÓ and not Òthe cup of the LordÓ (1
Cor 10:21); it is a cup that cannot fittingly symbolize the incorruptible and
Òprecious blood of ChristÓ (1 Peter 1:18-19). This gives us reason to believe
that the cup He ÒblessedÓ and gave to His disciples did not contain any
Òfermented thingÓ prohibited by Scripture.
The value of a
symbol is determined by its capacity to help us conceptualize and experience
the spiritual reality it represents.
Grape juice untouched by fermentation supplies life-sustaining nutrients
to our bodies, thus it has the capacity for helping us to conceptualize and to
experience the assurance of salvation represented by ChristÕs blood.
The
Survival of the Practice of Using Grape Juice
A fourth reason for believing that Jesus
used unfermented wine at the Last Supper, is found in the survival of the
practice of using grape juice.
For example, in the apocryphal Acts and Martyrdom of St. Matthew the Apostle, which circulated in the third century,
a heavenly voice instructs the local Bishop Plato, saying: ÒRead the Gospel and bring as an
offering the holy bread; and having pressed three clusters from the vine into a
cup, communicate with me, as the Lord Jesus showed us how to offer up when He
rose from the dead on the third day.Ó
This is a clear testimony of the use of freshly pressed grape juice in
the celebration of the LordÕs Supper.
The practice of
pressing grapes directly into the communion cup is attested by councils, popes
and theologians, including Thomas Aquinas (A. D.1225-1274). The use of
unfermented wine is well-dcumented
especially among such Eastern Churches as the Abyssinian Church, the Nestorian
Church of Western Asia, the Christians of St. Thomas in India, the Coptic
monasteries in Egypt, and the Christians of St. John in Persia, all of which
celebrated the LordÕs Supper with unfermented wine made either with fresh or
dried grapes. (For
documentation and references see chapter 5 of Wine in the Bible).
In
the light of the foregoing considerations we conclude that the Òthe fruit of
the vineÓ that Jesus commanded to be used as a memorial of His redeeming blood
was not fermented, which in the Scripture represents human corruption and
divine indignation, but unfermented and pure grape juice, a fitting emblem of
Christ's untainted blood shed for the remission of our sins.
The study of the language of the Last
Supper, the Passover law of fermentation, the consistency of the symbol and the
survival of the use of unfermented grape juice at the LordÕs Supper, all
indicate that Jesus abstained from all intoxicating substances and gave no
sanction to His followers to use them.
WINE IN THE
APOSTOLIC CHURCH
The importance of
the Apostolic Church as a model
for Christian beliefs and practices extends to her teachings on the use of
alcoholic beverages. The way
the apostles understood, preached and practiced the teachings of Jesus and of
the Old Testament regarding alcoholic beverages, is fundamental to determine
whether we as Christians today should take our stand on the side of moderation
or on the side of abstinence. We shall briefly examine first three wine-texts
and then the apostolic admonitions to abstinence.
Acts 2:13: ÒFilled with New WineÓ
The apostles had
scarcely begun their Messianic proclamation when they were accused of
drunkenness. On the day of
Pentecost the first company of believers received the gift of tongues enabling
them to preach the Gospel in the languages of the people gathered for the feast
at Jerusalem. While thousands
believed in Christ as a result of the miracle, others began mocking the
disciples, saying: ÒThey are
filled with new wine (gleukos)Ó (Acts 2:13).
Since gleukos is the term used to describe unfermented
grape juice, the irony of the charge is self-evident. What the mockers meant is ÒThese men, too abstemious to
touch anything fermented, have made themselves drunk on grape juice.Ó One can hardly fail to see in the irony
of the charge that the apostles were drunk on grape juice (their usual
beverage), an indirect but very important proof of their abstinent life-style
and inferentially of the abstemious life-style of their Teacher. For historical
confirmation of the abstinent life-style of the apostles, see Wine in the
Bible, p. 181
Ephesians 5:18: ÒDo not Get Drunk with WineÓ
A
powerful Biblical indictment against intoxicating wine is found in
Ephesians 5:18, where Paul admonishes the Ephesians, saying: ÒAnd do not get drunk with wine, for
that is debauchery; but be filled with the SpiritÓ (Eph 5:18, RSV). A literal
translation of the Greek text would read:
ÒAnd do not get drunk with wine, in which [en ho] is perdition [asotia—literally, ÔperditionÕ].Ó The RSV rendering of Òen ho—in whichÓ with Òfor thatÓ makes
the condition of being drunk with wine, rather than wine itself, the subject of
Òdebauchery/perdition.Ó This
construction of the sentence is based not on any exegetical necessity of the
text, but on the translatorsÕ assumption that the moderate use of fermented
wine was allowed in New Testament times.
Historically,
numerous translators and commentators have seen ÒwineÓ rather than the state of
drunkenness as the cause of debauchery.
For example, the famous Latin
Vulgate (about A. D. 400), reads: Òet nolite inebriari vino, in quo
est luxuriaÓ (ÒAnd be
not inebriated with wine, in which is voluptouosnessÓ). The connection between vino ÒwineÓ and quo ÒwhichÓ is unmistakable in this Latin
translation, because the relative quo has the same neuter gender of vino, upon which it depends.
Numerous modern
translations follow the Vulgate in its faithful literalness. For example, the French Synodal Version
reads: ÒNe vous enivrez pas de
vin: car le vin porte ˆ la dissolutionÓ (ÒDo not inebriate yourselves with
wine, for wine leads to dissolutenessÓ).
To remove any possibility for misunderstanding, the translators have
repeated the word ÒwineÓ in the relative clause. The same clear connection is found in the French translation
of David Martin, in the French Version dÕOstervald, in the margin of the New American Standard Bible, in the
Robert YoungÕs translation, in the Good News German Bible (ÒDie Gute
NachrichtÓ), in the Italian Protestant version Riveduta by Giovanni Luzzi, as
well as in the Italian Catholic Version produced by the Pontifical Biblical
Institute.
In the light of
the numerous ancient and modern translations which have rendered the relative
clause of Ephesians 5:18 as a condemnation, not of drunkenness but of wine
itself as the cause of perdition, it would appear that on account of their
predilection for wine some English translators have chosen to save the face of
wine by condemning drunkenness instead.
1 Timothy 5:23: ÒUse a Little Wine for the Sake of Your StomachÓ
When the subject
of wine in the Bible is brought up, the first text which seems to come to most
peopleÕs mind is 1 Timothy 5:23,
where Paul counsels Timothy saying:
ÒNo longer drink only water, but use a little wine for the sake of your
stomach and your frequent ailments.Ó This text has been used during the past
twentieth centuries by countless people to justify their drinking alcoholic
beverages. This popular view is
discredited by three major considerations:
¥ The
Implication of PaulÕs Advice
¥ The Form
of PaulÕs Advice
The Kind of Wine Used for Stomach
Disorders
The
Implication of PaulÕs Advice
PaulÕs advice ÒNo
longer drink only
waterÓ implies that Timothy, like the priests and Nazirites, had abstained
until that time from both fermented and unfermented wines, presumably in
accordance with the instructions and example of Paul. Earlier in the same epistle Paul tells him to require that a
Christian bishop be not only
abstinent (nephalion),
but also a non-participant at drinking places and parties (me paroinon—1 Tim 3:2-3). (For an analysis of
this text, see Wine in the Bible, pp. 206-210). It is
reasonable to assume that the apostle would not have instructed Timothy to
require abstinence of church leaders without first teaching him such a
principle. The fact that Timothy
had been drinking only water implies then that he had been following his
masterÕs counsel very scrupulously.
The abstinence of
a Christian minister was presumably based on the Old Testament legislation
prohibiting priests to use intoxicating drinks (Lev 10:9-10). The natural feeling would be that a
Christian minister should be no
less holy than a Jewish priest, especially since the reason for the Mosaic law remained the
same: ÒYou are to distinguish
between the holy and the common, and between the unclean and the clean; and you
are to teach the people of Israel all the statutes which the Lord has spoken to
them by MosesÓ (Lev 10:10-11). The
principle of abstinence was not violated by PaulÕs recommendation, because the
use of a little wine was recommended not for the pleasure of the belly but for
the medical need of the stomach.
The Form
of PaulÕs Advice
The form of PaulÕs advice Òtake a little
wine for your stomach sakeÓ sounds more like a medical prescription for stomach
disorder, than a concession to the pleasures of the belly. The apostle is not
ordering his beloved son in the Gospel to drink wine freely; rather he advises
him to use a little wine Òfor the sake of your stomach and your frequent
ailments.Ó
The prudent
caution of the apostleÕs language is most significant. He does not say, ÒNo longer drink
water,Ó but rather, ÒNo longer drink only water.Ó He
does not say, ÒDrink wine,Ó but rather Òuse a little wine with water.Ó He does not say, Òfor the physical
pleasure of your belly,Ó but rather, Òfor the medical need of your
stomach.Ó Even if the ÒwineÓ were
fermented, this text does not
support its regular use in any way. He did not say to Timothy, ÒDrink . . .Ó
but ÒTake . . . .Ó The verb Òtake-kraomaiÓ is used by a doctor when prescribing the dosage of a medication
to a patient. Similarly the
adjective Òlittle-oligosÓ implies a very moderate use of wine. This sounds more like a doctorÕs prescription to a patient
than a general principle for all people.
The Kind
of Wine Used for Stomach Disorders
It is generally
assumed that the wine Paul recommended to Timothy was alcoholic. But this is by no means certain, for
two reasons. First, because the
term oinos (ÒwineÓ),
as we have shown, was used in a
generic way to denote either fermented or unfermented wine. Second, because there are historical
testimonies attesting the use of unfermented wine for medical purposes.
Athenaeus, the
Grammarian (A.D. 280), specifically counsels the use of unfermented Òsweet
wineÓ (glukon oinon) for stomach disorders. He writes: ÒLet him take sweet wine, either mixed with water or warmed,
especially that kind called protropos, the sweet Lesbian glukus, as being good for the stomach; for
sweet wine [oinos]
does not make the head heavyÓ (Banquet 2, 24).
Here we have an advice which sounds strikingly similar to that of Paul,
with the difference that Athenaeus qualifies the kind of wine recommended,
namely, the sweet wine, called Òlesbian—effoeminatum,Ó because its alcoholic potency had been
removed.
A similar advice
regarding the medical use of wine
is given by Pliny (A. D. 79), a contemporary of Paul and author of the
celebrated Natural History. He recommends
using a boiled, unfermented wine
called adynamon for
sick persons Òfor whom it is feared that wine may be harmfulÓ (Natural
History 14,18). He also recommends using wines whose
alcohol content had been removed through filtration: ÒWines are most beneficial when all their potency has been
overcome by the strainerÓ (Natural History 23-24).
In light of these testimonies, it is
reasonable to assume that the wine recommended by Paul to Timothy may well have
been unfermented. Ellen White
supports this conclusion, saying: ÒPaul advised Timothy to take a little wine
for his stomachÕs sake and oft infirmities, but he meant the unfermented juice
of the grape. He did not advise
Timothy to take what the Lord had prohibitedÓ (The Signs of the Times, September 6, 1899: 6).
APOSTOLIC
ADMONITIONS TO ABSTINENCE
The
Apostolic admonitions to total abstinence constitute one of the most telling
indication of the biblical teaching on total abstinence. Several times Peter (1
Pet 1:13; 4:7; 5:8) and Paul (1 Thes 5:6-8; 2 Tim 4:5) urge believers to be
abstinent in preparation for ChristÕs coming. Unfortunately,
these admonitions are largely unknown
because the translatorsÕ bias render the verb nepho, which means Òne = do not, pino = drink,Ó as Òbe
sober.Ó There is noteworthy unanimity among Greek lexicons on the primary
meaning of the verb nepho as Òto abstain from wineÓ and of the adjective nephalios as Òabstinent, without wine.Ó For the
sake of brevity, we will look only at the two of Apostolic admonitions found in
1 Peter 1:13, and 1 Peter 4:7.
1 Peter
1:13: ÒFully AbstinentÓ
The admonition to
physical abstinence, expressed through the verb nepho,
occurs three times in the first epistle of Peter (1:13; 4:7; 5:8). It is noteworthy that in all the
three texts, PeterÕs exhortation to abstinence is given in the context of readiness for the
imminent return of Christ. This
implies that Peter, like Paul, grounds his call to a life of abstinence and
holiness in the certainty and imminence of ChristÕs return.
The first usage
of nepho by Peter
occurs in 1 Peter 1:13: ÒTherefore
gird up your minds, be sober [nephontes], set your hope fully upon the grace that is coming to you at the revelation of Jesus
Christ.Ó Here Peter, like Paul,
correlates mental vigilance (Ògird up your mindsÓ) with physical abstinence (Òbe
soberÓ).
The admonition to
Òbe abstinentÓ assumes a radical form in 1 Peter 1:13 because it is followed
immediately by the adverb Òteleios,Ó which means ÒperfectlyÓ or Òcompletely.Ó Thus, the correct translation is, Òbe
completely or perfectly abstinent.Ó
Unfortunately, most translators, presumably because of their
predilection for drinking, have chosen to make teleios
a modifier of the following verb elpisate
(Òset your hopeÓ), thus, rendering it Òset your hope fullyÓ (RSV).
It is noteworthy
that the Vulgate, JeromeÕs famous
Latin translation which has served as the official Catholic Bible throughout
the centuries, translates teleios as a modifier of nephontes, thus, Òsobrii perfecteÓ (Òperfectly soberÓ). In my view JeromeÕs translation reflects
accurately the intent of Peter, who repeats his call to abstinence twice again
in his epistle. Thus, the correct translation should be: ÒTherefore gird up your minds, being
wholly abstinent, set your hope upon the grace that is coming to you at the
revelation of Jesus Christ.Ó
1 Peter
4:7: ÒBe AbstinentÓ
The second usage of nepho occurs in 1 Peter 4:7:
ÒThe end of all things is
at hand; therefore keep sane [sophronesate] and sober [nepsate] for your prayers.Ó
Here again Peter exhorts Christians to be mentally vigilant and physically abstinent. The meaning of nepho as abstinence from wine is suggested
also by the context, where Peter contrasts the past life-style of
Òlicentiousness, passions, drunkenness, revels, carousing and lawless idolatryÓ (1 Pet 4:3) with
the new lifestyle of temperance and abstinence. The passage may be paraphrased
as follows: ÒThe end of all things
is at hand; therefore be sober in mind and abstemious in life in order that you
might be able to maintain a healthy devotional life at this critical time.Ó
The hope of a
soon-coming Savior calls for Christians to be Òmentally vigilantÓ (sophronesate) and physically abstinent (nepsate). The connection between mental
vigilance and physically abstinence is self evident, because alcohol impairs
the mental judgment, that is, the capacity to be mentally vigilant. It is
important to note that healthful and holy living is commended in the Scripture
not merely for the sake of personal health and goodness, but primarily for the
sake of GodÕs desire to dwell within us in this present life (1 Cor 3:16-17;
6:13) and to fellowship with us in the life to come.
BIBLICAL REASONS FOR ABSTINENCE
The Bible suggests four major reasons for
abstaining from alcoholic beverages:
¥ Mental
Effects
¥ Moral
Effects
¥ Physical
Effects
¥ Spiritual
Effects
Mental
Effects
Mentally, alcoholic beverages impairs the
capacity of the brain to make moral, responsible decisions. An important reason
the Bible disapproves drinking
alcoholic beverages, is because
they impair the capacity to think, to distinguish between right and wrong and
consequently to make responsible moral decisions. This truth expressed in Isaiah 28:7 where priests and
prophets are rebuked for having become Òconfused with wine,Ó erring in vision
and stumbling in judgment. The
Talmud brings out this truth most graphically when it says: ÒWhen the wine enters the system of a
person, out goes sense, wherever there is wine there is no understanding.Ó
It was because of
this concern that God gave this specific instruction to Aaron concerning the
priests: ÒDrink no wine [yayin]
nor strong drink, you nor your sons with you, when you go into the tent of
meeting, lest you die; it shall be a statute for ever throughout your
generations. You are to
distinguish between the holy and the common, and between the unclean and the
clean; and you are to teach the people of Israel all the statutes which the
Lord has spoken to them by MosesÓ (Lev 10:9-11).
The specific
reason given for the prohibition to drink alcoholic beverages is that these
would impair the priestsÕ ability to distinguish between the holy and the
profane and to teach the people GodÕs commandments. The same reason is repeated in EzekielÕs vision of the new
Temple, where priests are enjoined to abstain from intoxicating wine in order
that they may be able to Òteach my people the difference between the holy and
the common, and [to] show them how to distinguish between the unclean and the
cleanÓ (Ezek 44:23).
The same
injunction is given to civil servants. The wise Solomon clearly states that
kings and rulers must not drink wine:
ÒIt is not for kings, O Lemuel, it is not for kings to drink wine [yayin], or for rulers to desire strong drinkÓ
(Prov 31:4). The reason for this
explicit injunction is immediately given,
Òlest they drink and forget what has been decreed, and pervert the
rights of all the afflictedÓ (Prov 31:5).
As in the case of
the priests, kings and rulers are enjoined to abstain from alcoholic wine,
because this would impair their remembrance of the laws and consequently their
capacity to be just in the judicial duties which, in ancient times, kings
frequently discharged in person.
This text offers
another example where Scripture makes a value judgment on alcoholic wine
itself, rather than on the quantity drunk. The text does not say, Òit is not for kings to drink much wine.Ó Rather it says, ÒIt is not for kings to drink wine.Ó What is here prohibited, is not, as
many claim, the abuse but the actual use of alcoholic beverages, because they
impair the capacity of the brain to make moral, responsible decisions.
Moral
Effects
A second reason the Bible disapproves the
use of alcoholic beverages, is because they weakens moral inhibitions. This truth is expressed through stories
and admonitions. The classic example of this phenomenon is, of course, the case
of Noah: ÒAnd he drank of the wine
[yayin], and became
drunk, and lay uncovered in his tentÓ (Gen 9:21).
Another
illustration is the case of LotÕs daughters who used wine successfully to
weaken the moral restraints of their father: ÒCome, let us make our father drink wine [yayin] and we will lie with him, that we may
preserve offspring through our fatherÓ (Gen 19:32).
The example of
LotÕs daughters in their use of wine to weaken sexual inhibitions, has been
followed by countless people throughout the centuries. This trend is so well accepted today
that in most TV soap operas drinking precedes and predisposes people to illicit
sexual relationships. In ancient Israel
this happened without any inducement from soap operas. Habakkuk, for example, condemns such
social evil, saying: ÒWoe to him
who makes his neighbors drink of the cup of his wrath, and makes them drunk, to
gaze on their shame!Ó (Hab 2:15;
cf. Lam 4:21).
The potential of
alcoholic beverages to weaken moral sensitivity and to awaken evil
inclinations, is an important reason for their biblical prohibition.
Physical
Effects
A third reason
the Bible disapproves the use of alcoholic beverages, is because of their
physical effects. These are
described not in medical terms, but in a colorful language that people could
understand. It compares the intoxicating effects of wine to the bite of a
serpent and the sting of a viper (Prov 23:32).
Hosea mentions
how wine made the princes sick on the occasion of what may have been the kingÕs
coronation or birthday: ÒOn the
day of our king the princes became sick with the heat of wine [yayin]Ó (Hos 7:5). The term ÒheatÓ translates the Hebrew hemah which is often used to describe the
inflaming, poisonous influence of wine (Deut 32:33; Jer 51:39). In Deuteronomy 32:33; for example, the
term hemah is translated ÒpoisonÓ:
ÒTheir wine is the poison (hemah) of serpents.Ó
Thus, in Hosea the cause of the sickness of the princes is attributed to
Òthe poison of wine.Ó
This description
of wine as a sickening poison shows that Scripture does not hesitate to expose
in frightening terms the danger of intoxicating wine. Today medical science
confirms the harmful effects of
alcoholic beverages to the liver, the brain, the stomach, and the heart.
The most serious liver disease caused by alcohol consumption is cirrhosis. This is a disease in which liver cells
are destroyed and thus the organ is no longer able to process the nutrients in
the food. Approximately
30,000 Americans die of cirrhosis every year.
Spiritual
Effects
A fourth reason
the Bible disapproves the use of alcoholic beverages, is because they inhibit
spiritual growth by impairing the capacity of the mind to be renewed in the
image of God. It is important to remember that spiritual growth takes place
through the renewing of the mind (Eph 4:23-24; Col 3:10). ÒBe renewed in the
spirit of your minds, and put on the new nature, created after the likeness of GodÓ (Eph 4:23-24). Through
our minds our body becomes the temple of the Holy Spirit (1 Cor 6:19).
The image of God
in humans is found in the rational capacity of the brain. By impairing the
brain, alcohol and drugs destroy GodÕs image in people and pollute their body
temple (1 Cor 6:19). The ultimate
result is perdition, that is, the loss of eternal life. ÒDo not get drunk with
wine, for wine leads to perdition-asotia; but be filled with the SpiritÓ (Eph
5:18).
The Biblical
warnings against the mental, moral, physical, and spiritual dangers inherent in
intoxicating wine have special significance for us as Christians who believe
that our bodies are the handiwork of God (Gen 2:7; Ps 139:13-15) and the temple
of the Holy Spirit (1 Cor 3:16-17; 6:19-20). To destroy our health by means of intoxicating substances
means to destroy GodÕs temple within us, Òfor GodÕs temple is holy, and that
temple you areÓ (1 Cor 3:17).
For Christians
who believe in the certainty and imminence of ChristÕs Return, the apostolic
admonitions to abstain from intoxicating beverages, assumes added significance:
it represents a tangible response to God's invitation to make concrete
preparation for the second coming of Christ.
Conclusion. The Biblical teachings regarding the use
of alcoholic beverages can be summarized in one sentence: the Scripture is
consistent in teaching moderation in the use of wholesome, unfermented
beverages and abstinence from the use of intoxicating fermented beverages.
The practical implication of this conclusion can also be stated in one
sentence: when we accept the Biblical teaching that drinking alcoholic
beverages is not only physically harmful but also morally wrong, we will feel
compelled not only to abstain ourselves from intoxicating substances, but also
to help others to do likewise.
ANNOUNCEMENTS
OF SERVICES AND PRODUCTS
SPECIAL
FIRST TIME OFFER OF 10 DVD/CD ALBUMS FOR ONLY $150.00, INSTEAD OF THE REGULAR
PRICE OF $950.00
This offer may sound too good to be true.
For the first time I am offering together as a package all the 10 DVD/CD
albums, containing the recordings of Prof. Jon Paulien, Prof. Graeme Bradford,
and my own. Until now I have offered all these recordings separately, costing
considerably more. To make it
possible for many to benefit from all these timely messages, I have decided to
offer them together as a package for only $150.00, instead of the regular price of $950.00.
THE
PACKAGE INCLUDES THE FOLLOWING 10ALBUMS:
1)
Prof. Jon Paulien's newly released DVD ALBUM video seminar on Simply
Revelation.
2)
Prof. Jon Paulien's CD ALBUM with a dozen of his books, and all his articles.
3)
Prof. Graeme Bradford's DVD ALBUM with a two hours video lecture on Ellen
White. He shares the highlights of his book More than a Prophet. The album contains also Prof.
Bradford's the publications and articles.
4)
Prof. Bacchiocchi's newly recorded DVD ALBUM called ABUNDANT LIFE SEMINAR. The album contains 2 video powerpoint lectures: The
Christian and Alcoholic Beverages and How to Build a Happy and Lasting Marriage. These two lectures summarize the
highlights of BacchiocchiÕs two books Wine in the Bible and The Marriage Covenant. Two separate files with 225 powerpoint
slides are included.
5)
Prof. Bacchiocchi's DVD ALBUM containing 10 video powerpoint lectures on the
Sabbath and Second Advent. Some of
the lectures show the documents Prof. Bacchiocchi found in Vatican libraries on
the role of the papacy in changing the Sabbath to Sunday. This album contains
the popular powerpoint SABBATH/ADVENT seminars Prof. Bacchiocchi presents in
many countries.
6)
Prof. Bacchiocchi's DVD ALBUM on Cracking the Da Vinci Code. The album contains a two hours video
lecture, professionally taped with a vitual studio as a background. A separate
file with 200 powerpoint slides is included.
7)
Prof. Bacchiocchi's DVD ALBUM on The Mark and the Number of the Beast. The album contains the two hours
video lecture and a separate powerpoint file with the 200 slides used for the
lecture.
8)
Prof. Bacchiocchi's CD ALBUM with
all his books and powerpoint lectures. The album consists of two disks. The
first disk has all his 18 books and over 200 articles. The second disk has the
slides and script of 25 of Prof. Bacchiocci's popular PowerPoint presentations.
9)
Prof. Bacchiocchi's DVD ALBUM on The
Passion of Christ. The album contains the 2 hours live
interview conducted by 3ABN on Prof. Bacchiocchi's book The Passion of
Christ in Scripture and History.
10)
Prof. Bacchiocchi's MP3 AUDIO ALBUM which contains 2 disks with 22 AUDIO
lectures on vital biblical beliefs and practices. Ideal for listening in your
car while driving.
HOW
TO ORDER THE PACKAGE OF THE 10 ALBUMS
You
can see the picture of all the 10 ALBUMS and read a detailed description of them, just by clicking
at this URL address:
http://www.biblicalperspectives.com/albumoffer.htm
You
can order the complete package of 10 DVD/CD Albums for only $150.00, instead of the regular price of
$950.00, in four different ways:
(1) Online: By clicking here: http://www.biblicalperspectives.com/albumoffer.htm
(2) Phone: By calling us at (269) 471-2915 to give us your credit card
number and postal address.
(3) Email: By emailing your order to <[email protected]>. Be sure to provide your postal address, credit card number, and expiration date.
(4)
Regular Mail: By mailing
a check for $150.00 to BIBLICAL
PERSPECTIVES, 4990 Appian Way, Berrien Springs, Michigan 49103, USA. We
guarantee to process your order immediately.
NEWLY
RELEASED DVD OF PROF. JON PAULIENÕS LIVE SEMINAR ON SIMPLY REVELATION
Prof. Jon
PaulienÕs DVD album on SIMPLY REVELATION was released few weeks ago. We have been airmailing the DVD album to church leaders,
pastors, and lay Adventists in different part of the world. Several pastors
have already shown the lectures to their congregations. They wrote to me saying that viewing
the lectures was an enlightening experience for their members.
My wife and I
viewed Simply Revelation on our TV on a Sabbath afternoon. Though I had already watched
Prof. PaulienÕs lectures during the taping session, I was spellbound to hear
him again offering so many refreshing insights into the most difficult book of
the Bible. For me it is a thrilling experience listening to a scholar like
Prof. Paulien, who knows what he is talking about.
Prof. Paulien
is one of the most respected Adventist scholars. Besides serving as the
chairman of the New Testament at Andrews University Theological Seminary, he
writes and lectures extensively in many parts of the world. He is rightly
regarded as a leading Adventist authority on the book of Revelation which he
has taught at the Seminary for the past 20 years. His doctoral dissertation as
well as several of his books deal specifically with the Book of Revelation.
The constant
demand for Prof. PaulienÕs CD album with his publications and articles, led me
to discuss with him the possibility of producing a live video recording of a
mini Revelation Seminar, which he chose to call Simply Revelation. As suggested by its title, Simply Revelation aims to simply present the message of
Revelation—not to read into Revelation sensational, but senseless views.
The preparation
of this video recording took several months. The Simply Revelation seminar consists of four one-hour
live video lectures,
which have just been recorded in the studio of Andrews University. An
impressive virtual studio provides the background of the lectures. Each lecture
is delivered with about 50 powerpoint slides. I have spent long hours looking for suitable pictures to
illustrate the text of each slide in order to enhance the visual effect of each
lecture. This mini Revelation seminar will offer you and your congregation
fresh insights into the Book of Revelation. Be sure to inform your pastor about
the newly released Simply Revelation, if he is not aware of it.
You will be
pleased to know that we have placed on a separate file all the powerpoint
slides and text used for the live video presentations. Each slide has the
script of the live lecture. This
means that if you are a pastor or a lay member who want to use Prof. PaulienÕs Simply
Revelation Seminar,
you can pick and choose the powerpoint slides that you like.
The file with
the powerpoint slides is placed on Prof. PaulienÕs CD album containing all his
publications and articles. The
reason is that there was no memory left on the DVD disks. In spite of my pleas, Prof. Paulien was
so full of the subject that he used the full 60 minutes of his four lecture,
leaving no space for the slidesÕ file.
This has been a
very expensive project, both in time and money. The regular price of the DVD album is $100.00, but you can
order it now until July 30, at the introductory price of only $50.00. The price includes the airmailing expenses to any overseas
destination.
If you have not
ordered before the CD Album with Prof. PaulienÕs publications, we will be glad to add it to your DVD
order for only $20.00, instead of the regular price of $60.00. This means that
you can order both the DVD album with Prof. PaulienÕs four live video
lectures on Revelation and his CD album with all his publications and powerpoint slides of Simply
Revelation, for only
$70.00, instead of the
regular price of $160.00.
As an
additional incentive, I am offering you together with Prof. PaulienÕs DVD/CD
albums, also my own popular DVD album on The Mark and Number of the Beast, for an additional $10.00, instead of the regular price of
$100.00. This means that
you can order the DVD and CD albums by Prof, Paulien, together with my DVD
album on The Mark and Number of the Beast, for only $80.00, instead of the
regular price of $260.00.
This
research on The Mark and Number of the Beast, was commissioned
by Prof. Paulien himself. He asked me to trace historically the origin and
use of the PopeÕs title Vicarius Filii Dei and
of the number 666. I spent six months conducting this investigation which
was professionally taped at the Andrews University Towers Auditorium. I use
200 powerpoint slides to deliver this informative two hours lecture which
is warmly received by Adventist church leaders and pastors in many parts of
the world. For a detailed description of this DVD album click: http://www.biblicalperspectives.com/Beast/BeastPromo
SPECIAL
OFFER ON PAULIEN/BACCHIOCCHIÕS ALBUMS
*
ONE DVD Album of Prof. PaulienÕs four video lectures on Simply Revelation at the introductory price of $50.00,
instead of $100.00. The price includes the airmailing
expenses to any overseas destination.
*
ONE DVD Album of Simply Revelation and ONE CD Album with Prof. PaulienÕs publications for
only $70.00, instead of
the regular price of $160.00. The price includes the airmailing expenses to any overseas destination.
*
ONE DVD Album of Simply Revelation, ONE CD
Album with Prof. PaulienÕs publications, and ONE DVD Album with BacchiocchiÕs
two hours video lecture on The Mark and Number of the Beast for only $80.00, instead of the regular price of $260.00.
The price includes the airmailing expenses to any
overseas destination.
FOUR
WAYS TO ORDER
(1) Online: By clicking here: http://www.biblicalperspectives.com/revelation/
(2) Phone:
By calling us at (269) 471-2915 to give us your credit card number and
postal address.
(3) Email: By emailing your order to <[email protected]>. Be sure to provide your postal address, credit card number, and expiration date.
(4) Regular
Mail: By mailing a check
to BIBLICAL PERSPECTIVES, 4990
Appian Way, Berrien Springs, Michigan 49103, USA. We guarantee to process your
order immediately.
NEW
EDITION OF BRADFORDÕS MORE THAN A PROPHET
The
new edition Prof. Graeme BradfordÕs book More than a Prophet with an additional 20 pages, was released
few weeks ago. Many churches have ordered the book by the case of 30 copies for
only $150.00, that is, $5.00 per copy, instead of the regular price of $25.00.
This book is urgently needed to restore confidence in the prophetic ministry of
Ellen White by telling the truth about her divine revelations and her human
limitations.
The
most gratifying responses have come from former Adventist. One lady wrote:
ÒAfter reading More than a Prophet, I am seriously reconsidering returning to the Adventist church.Ó
It is unfortunate that many Adventists have left the church, because they felt
that they had been deceived about Ellen White. They could not reconcile in
their mind that prophets do make mistakes. But Prof. Bradford compellingly
shows that the mistakes found in the Bible or in the writings of Ellen White,
do not negate the divine inspiration of their messages.
For
a detailed description of More than a Prophet, together with the reviews and a picture
of the book, click at this link: http://www.biblicalperspectives.com/BradfordOffer/offer.htm
To
facilitate the distribution of this timely book among your church members, we
are offering you two things:
1)
Special discount on quantity orders of the book. Only $5.00 per copy, instead of $25.00
for a case of 30 copies.
2) A
FREE ALBUM of Prof. BradfordÕs DVD with a live two hours lecture on Ellen
White. The DVD contains also a PDF file with
all of Prof. BardfordÕs books and articles. The regular price of the DVD album
is $100.00, but you will receive it FREE with an order of 2 or more copies of
More than a Prophet.
The
reason for offering a Free Album of Prof. BradfordÕs DVD live lecture on Ellen
White, is to give your members the opportunity to enjoy the highlights of the
More than a Prophet. After viewing the DVD, most members are eager to order the book.
SPECIAL
OFFER ON MORE THAN A PROPHET
ONE
COPY of More than a Prophet for $20.00
(instead of $25.00), plus $5.00 for mailing in the USA, or $10.00 for
airmailing overseas.
TWO
COPIES of More than a Prophet plus the DVD album with Prof. BradfordÕs live two hours
lecture on Ellen White, for $50.00 (instead of the regular price of $150.00). Add $10.00 for
airmailing overseas.
THIRTY
COPIES of More than a Prophet plus the DVD album with Prof. BradfordÕs live two hours
lecture on Ellen White, for only $150.00, instead of the regular price of $850.00. The price includes
the mailing in the USA. Unfortunately as of May 14, 2007, the USA Post
office no longer offers surface mail service for overseas. Everything must be
sent AIRMAIL. The
cost for airmailing a case of 30 books, is $95.00. Thus, the total cost for a
case of 30 copies AIRMAILED overseas is $245.00. The advantage is that you will
receive the case within a week.
FOUR
WAYS TO ORDER
(1)
Online: By clicking
here: http://www.biblicalperspectives.com/BradfordOffer/offer.htm
(2) Phone: By calling us at (269) 471-2915 to give
us your credit card number and postal address.
(3) Email: By emailing your order to <[email protected]>. Be sure to provide your postal address, credit card number, and expiration date.
(4)
Regular Mail: By mailing
a check to BIBLICAL PERSPECTIVES,
4990 Appian Way, Berrien Springs,
Michigan 49103, USA. We guarantee to process your order immediately.
UPCOMING
SEMINARS FOR THE MONTHS OF
AUGUST,AND SEPTEMBER
Gradually I am rescheduling some of the invitations I had to cancel
because of the colon cancer surgery and liver treatments. Here is a list of the
upcoming weekend seminars for the months of August,and September.
AUGUST
17-18: WHITE MEMORIAL SDA CHURCH
Location:
401 North State Street, Los Angeles, CA 90033. This is one of the most
beautiful Adventist churches that was ever built. It can seat over 2000 people. When in 1962 Loma Linda
University decided to relocate its students and faculty to a consolidated
campus in Loma Linda, the membership gradually declined from over 2000 to the
current 350.
I
have reasons to believe that the new senior Pastor Benjamin Del Pozo, D. Min.,
will build up the attendance. He is a creative thinker and a good
communicator. He speaks with his
hands like an Italian. (Please laugh!)
He invited me twice at the Temple City SDA Church where he has served
for several years, doubling the attendance. For directions amd information call Pastor Benjamin Del Pozo
at (626) 292-1305 or 323-440-1200.
AUGUST
31 - SEPTEMBER 1: DAYTONA BEACH
SDA CHURCH
Location:
401 North Williamson Blvd, Daytona Beach, FL 32114.
For
directions and information call Pastor William Barrett at (386) 258-1073.
SEPTEMBER
7-8: FRIENDS OF THE SABBATH CONFERENCE
Location:
The Lecture Hall, Knoxville Convention Center, 701 Henley Street, Knoxville, TN
37920. This Sabbath Conference is
organized by English Prof. Bruce Horne, Ph. D., a leader of the Seventh-day
Christian Assembly in Knoxville with about 120 members. Several non-SDA
sabbatarian churches and groups from neighboring states are participating at
this Sabbath Conference.
Adventists
living in the Knoxville area are encouraged to attend this Sabbath
Conference. I will be the keynote
speaker on Friday evening and Saturday. We are planning also for a panel
discussion conducted by church leaders of various sabbatarian churches. This will be a unique opportunity to
become acquainted with other sabbatarians. For directions and information call Prof. Bruce Horne at
(865) 671-4342 or (423) 914-5475.
SEPTEMBER
15: WORLDÕS WOMANÕS CHRISTIAN TEMPERANCE UNION CONFERENCE
Location:
AdamÕs Mark Hotel, 2544 Executive Drive, Indianapolis, IN 46241. The hotel
phone number is: (317) 248-2481.
This is the international WorldÕs WomanÕs Christian Temperance Union
that brings together WWCTU delegates of different denominations from all over the
world.
Ellen
White was very active in this organization and was often featured as the
keynote speaker. Our Adventist church had an active Temperance program in
the past. Today we hear little from our pulpit about Temperance, partly because
alcohol and drugs are seen more as a medical than a moral issue.
I
have been invited to deliver the keynote address on Saturday, September 15,
2007 at 10: 30 a. m. Prior to my lecture, there will be a church service from
9:00 to 10:00 a. m. My powerpoint lecture is entitled ÒThe Christian and
Alcoholic Beverages.Ó I will be sharing the highlights of my book Wine in the
Bible, dealing with the biblical imperative of total abstinence. If you live in
the Indianapolis area, I would urge you to attend the meetings, especially on
Saturday. For directions and more detail information, contact Sarah R. Ward,
WWCTU President, at (765) 345-2306
SEPTEMBER
21-22: HAWAII SAMOA-TOKELAU CHURCH
Location:
1128 Banyan Street, Honolulu, Hawaii 96817.
For
directions and information call Pastor Michael Asuega at (808) 261-7321 or
(808) 206 5892.
SEPTEMBER
28-29: HONOLULU CENTRAL SDA CHURCH
Location:
2313 Nuuanu Avenue, Honolulu, Hawaii 96817. This will be the Hawaii Conference
Convocation for all the churches in Oahu.
For
directions and information, call the Hawaii Conference Office at (808)
595-7591.
INCREDIBLE
NEW OFFERS ON HITACHI PROJECTORS
HITACHI
has just released the new CP-X400 3000 lumens projector, which replaces the
CP-X444. The new projector has an
impressive high resolution, low fan noise, and a wealth of connectivity
options. The most impressive feature of this projector is the incredible price
of only $1395.00 to
help especially our churches and schools in developing countries.
This is
the special offer on the following three models:
CP-X260
HIGH RESOLUTION 2500 LUMENS - Only $1095.00
Previous SDA
price for the 2500 lumens was $2395.00.
CP-X400
HIGH RESOLUTION 3000 LUMENS - Only $1395.00
This is the
lowest price for an HITACHI 3000 lumens projector.
CP-X1250
HIGH RESOLUTION 4500 LUMENS Only $3795.00
Previous SDA
price for the 4500 lumens was $4900.00.
WARRANTY: The above prices include a 3 years 24/7
replacement warranty worth about $285.00.
You can
order the HITACHI projectors online by clicking at this link: http://www.biblicalperspectives.com/cart/catalog/index.php?cPath=24
If you
have a problem ordering online, call us at (269) 471-2915. We will take your order by phone. Your
order will be processed immediately.
THE
SMALLEST, MOST POWERFUL REMOTE PRESENTER
If you are looking for an outstanding REMOTE for your PowerPoint
presentations, you will be pleased to know HONEYWELL has just come out with the
smallest and most powerful remote in the market.
The size of the transmitter is smaller than a credit card. You can stick
it inside the palm of your hand and nobody can see it. I tested the remote in
an open environment, and the radio signal can go up to 400 feet of distance. IT
IS INCREDIBLE! The transmitter has three button: forward, backward, and laser.
You
can order online the new POWERPOINT PRESENTER simply by clicking here: http://www.biblicalperspectives.com/cart/catalog/product_info.php?cPath=27&products_id=67
If
you have a problem ordering online, simply call us at (269) 471-2915. We will take your order by phone. You
can also email us your order at <[email protected]>,
giving us your address, credit card number, and expiration date.
DOES
YOUR CHURCH OR SCHOOL NEED A SCREEN?
If your church/school is looking for a screen, the DA-LITE SCREEN
COMPANY, the largest manufacture of screens in the world, has agreed to offer
their line of screens to our Adventist churches and schools at about 30%
discount.
The
procedure is very simple. Visit the DA-LITE SCREEN COMPANY website at http://www.da-lite.com.
You will see hundreds of models of screens with their respective prices. Once
you find the screen that you need, give us the model number by phone (269)
471-2915 or email your request <[email protected]>
We will forward your order immediately to DA-LITE that will ship the screen
directly to your address. You will receive the screen at about 30% discount.
BED
& BREAKFAST FACILITIES IN LONDON, ENGLAND
If
your travel plans call for a stop in London, you will be pleased to learn
about a most gracious Adventist couple that offer the best accommodation and
breakfast I have ever enjoyed. It has become my home away from home when in
London. See details at: http://www.biblicalperspectives.com/Promotions/BED&BREAKFAST.htm
TAGNET
SPECIAL NEW WEB HOSTING OFFER FOR ADVENTIST CHURCHES AND MEMBERS
TAGnet
provides an incredible number of webhosting services to our churches and members.
This newsletter comes to you through their gracious and efficient service.
For detail information, visit their website at http://www.netadventist.org
or http://home.tagnet.org/
You may also call their office 800 - 9TAGNET. They are ready and eager to
help you.